23
By all measures, cash for clunkers has been a wild success. More than 700,000 cars have been sold in about 3 weeks. Even though some claim that only 200,000 of those would not have been sold at some point otherwise, that’s still huge. And all of this has cost $3B of taxpaper money.
The leverage, however, has been huge. If the average sale is $20,000, and the average rebates is $4,000, there’s a 5x multiplier on a boost to the economy. I don’t know what other stimulus funds have had a 5x boost.
I strongly feel we should reduce the cash for clunkers fee to $2,000 for two months, and then $1,000 for two months and allow up to $5B or $10B more, since we can then get 10x or 20x multiplier at that reduced amount.
I feel that we need to find more of this kind of stimulus – if we are going to provide stimulus at all. We gave $50B to the car companies immediately and got nothing like this bang for the buck – for less than 1/5th that amount we could do so much more.
Am I missing something here? I’d love to hear what any downside of this could be.